Anna Maria Island, located along Florida’s Gulf Coast, is a paradise for beach enthusiasts and a haven for those seeking delightful sweet treats. In this article, we’ll take you through the island’s culinary scene, highlighting the top spots to indulge in irresistible desserts. From cozy cafés to vibrant ice cream parlors and charming restaurants, Anna Maria Island offers diverse options to satisfy your cravings!
Join us as we uncover the hidden gems that will make your visit to this enchanting island even sweeter!
Anna Maria Island Creamery & Bakery
Located at the heart of Anna Maria Island, the Anna Maria Island Creamery & Bakery is a must-visit destination for those seeking a delectable Anna Maria Island dessert. As a family-owned establishment, this creamery and bakery store prides itself on offering a delightful array of original handmade Italian Gelato, Sorbets, pastries, assorted desserts, handmade truffles, and locally roasted gourmet coffee specialties.
This charming creamery and bakery perfectly encapsulate the island’s laid-back vibe and coastal charm. With superb restaurants, vibrant Anna Maria Island shops, colorful houses, swaying palm trees, and seven miles of pristine white beaches, this stunning beach town creates an atmosphere that instantly relaxes locals and visitors alike.
Hometown Desserts
Hometown Desserts, a local gem on Anna Maria Island, is the go-to destination for custom creations and delectable treats. Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, anniversary, graduation, or a special occasion, their custom cakes, cookies, and cake pops will add a sweet touch to your event. Their exquisite wedding cakes perfectly complement the beauty of an Anna Maria Island sunset beach ceremony.
But Hometown Desserts doesn’t stop there! Their delicious treats can also be found at numerous Anna Maria Island restaurants, ensuring you can enjoy their delectable offerings even when dining on the island. They can also print edible logos and messages on cookies and cupcakes, making them a delightful addition to your party desserts or goody bags!
Dips Ice Cream
Dips Ice Cream is different from your average ice cream shop on Anna Maria Island. While it satisfies your cravings for delectable frozen treats, it offers much more. Step inside, and you’ll discover a delightful combination of an ice cream parlor, candy store, and sports shop.
This gem is a haven for adults seeking nostalgic delights. Indulge in throwback candies like bottle caps, wax lips, and jawbreakers that will transport you back to simpler times. Meanwhile, kids will be delighted by the abundance of delicious refined sugar and the fun, dotted ice cream pellets that add a whimsical touch to their treats.
With over 30 flavors of ice cream, including non-dairy options, Dips Ice Cream ensures something for everyone’s taste buds. Whether you crave classic favorites or want to try something new, their wide variety of flavors guarantees a delightful experience.
Two Scoops
Located in Bayview Plaza at the North End of Anna Maria Island, Two Scoops Ice Cream Parlor & Coffee Café is a delightful destination for ice cream lovers and coffee enthusiasts. This family-owned establishment has been serving homemade ice cream since its opening in October 2007, quickly becoming an island favorite.
With an impressive selection of 32 flavors of homemade ice cream, Two Scoops guarantees a scoop for every palate. From classic favorites to unique creations, their ice cream is made with love and attention to detail, and it’s easy to see why this is the top Anna Maria Island ice cream spot! Whether craving a traditional flavor or feeling adventurous enough to try something new, Two Scoops has you covered.
In addition to their exceptional ice cream, Two Scoops also offers a cozy coffee café where you can enjoy a warm cup of freshly brewed coffee, adding a perfect complement to your sweet treat experience.
Gelato-go Anna Maria Island
Indulge in the authentic taste of Italy at Gelato-go Anna Maria Island. This delightful gelateria takes pride in crafting its gelato base daily, using only the freshest ingredients. The secret to their exceptional gelato lies in the meticulous search for the finest ingredients sourced from Italy and around the globe.
With each bite, you’ll experience the rich flavors and creamy textures that make Italian gelato so beloved. From classic favorites like stracciatella and pistachio to innovative creations like tiramisu and fruity sorbets, Gelato-go offers various flavors to satisfy every palate.
Plan Your Visit
Searching for the perfect hotel to call home during your vacation? Book your stay in one of the top Anna Maria Island Hotels, Anna Maria Island Inn! Our resort hotel offers you the perfect place to relax and unwind during your getaway and more amenities than you can count. Don’t just take our word for it! View all of our accommodations and find the perfect place for your getaway today!
Mademoiselle Paris French Restaurant & Bakery
Experience the charm of France at Mademoiselle Paris French Restaurant & Bakery. Owned by Jean and Myriam Dandonneau, this authentic establishment combines a bakery and a French bistro.
Start your day with freshly baked pastries, bread, and viennoiseries prepared by their talented chefs each morning. Indulge in a delectable array of pastries like Opera, Black Forest, and Napoleon, crafted by their pastry chef, Brittany.
The Donut Experiment
Satisfy your donut cravings with a visit to The Donut Experiment on Anna Maria Island. Created by the husband-and-wife team of Shawn and Cecilia Wampole, this donut shop is a labor of love and a delightful experiment in flavor and creativity.
Shawn and Cecilia wanted to create a boutique-style donut shop that offered every visitor a fun and exciting experience. At The Donut Experiment, customers can watch as their donuts are made before them and can choose their toppings and flavors. This personalized approach has resonated with both residents and visitors, making The Donut
Experiment with one of the most popular restaurants on Anna Maria Island.
The Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe
Indulge in pure bliss for your taste buds at The Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe. This charming establishment is dedicated to creating freshly made baked goods every day, using the finest and most delicious local ingredients.
Every treat is handcrafted with love and attention to detail, from their signature cheesecakes to their irresistible “Scuties” (scrumptious mini cheesecakes). Whether planning a day at the beach, organizing a special event, or simply looking to treat someone sweet, their Cheesecake Cutie boxes, cold salads, and “CharCUTIErie” boxes are perfect choices.
At The Cheesecake Cutie & Cafe, they believe that nothing expresses care more than something handcrafted with love. Whether you’re a resident or a visitor to the area, their fresh bakery sweets and cafe treats will surely delight your taste buds.
Where to Stay
When you’re looking for hotels on Anna Maria Island, look no further than Anna Maria Island Inn. As a unique resort hotel, we offer a diverse range of accommodations across eight distinct locations, ensuring there’s something for everyone’s preferences and needs.
From luxurious beachfront retreats to spacious family suites by the pool, our accommodations cater to all types of travelers. Whether you prefer a comfortable beachside guest room or desire the tranquility of tropically landscaped outdoor spaces, Anna Maria Island Inn has you covered. Take a dip in our resort-style pools, bask in the sun on pristine beaches, and create unforgettable memories during your beach vacation.
At Anna Maria Island Inn, our guests are our top priority. We pride ourselves on providing exceptional service and ensuring your stay is as enjoyable as possible. With our 24/7 onsite team, you can rest assured that assistance is always just a phone call away.
Experience the beauty and tranquility of Anna Maria Island by choosing Anna Maria Island Inn as your home away from home. Your beach vacation awaits, and we’re here to make it one you won’t forget. Find the perfect Anna Maria Island accommodations for your next getaway, and book your stay today!
