Have a Yummy Meal at Anna Maria Island Seafood Restaurants

Visiting Anna Maria Island should be at the top of your traveling bucket list. The island is a tropical haven with its dazzling beaches, captivating sunsets, and serene atmosphere. But there’s more to this island than meets the eye. Nestled amid the idyllic surroundings are some of the most delectable seafood restaurants you’ll ever encounter!

With everything from classic favorites to new dishes filled with local flavors, there’s something for everyone at these amazing Anna Maria Island restaurants!

In this guide, we’ll dive deep into the top seafood restaurants on Anna Maria Island, which you’ll have to sample when staying in one of our Anna Maria Island Accommodations!

Sandbar Seafood & Spirits

There’s a magic that encapsulates Anna Maria Island, and it finds its true spirit at the Sandbar Seafood & Spirits. This isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an experience deeply rooted in Old Florida traditions. Authenticity radiates in every dish, every breeze, and every sunset you witness here.

Have you ever dined while feeling the gentle sand beneath your feet, with the magnificent Gulf of Mexico offering a sunset performance right before you? If not, Sandbar beckons you to live this magical moment. Come here to enjoy delectable seafood dishes while sipping on tropical drinks, basking in the sun, and beautiful Anna Maria Island weather with the soft murmur of waves in the background!

The Waterfront Restaurant

On the picturesque shores of Anna Maria Island lies a dining gem that evokes the timeless charm of old Florida: The Waterfront Restaurant. More than just a place to dine, The Waterfront offers its patrons the chance to return to a simpler era when Florida was all about tropical vibes, unhurried moments, and the pure joy of savoring life.

At the heart of The Waterfront’s appeal is its meticulously crafted menu, a testament to classic American cuisine. The dishes echo a commitment to quality and authenticity, featuring fresh seafood, sumptuous salads, and perfectly grilled steaks. 

But the culinary journey doesn’t end with the food. The Waterfront also boasts a craft bar, an oasis for spirit enthusiasts seeking rare and unique concoctions for a genuinely unparalleled drinking experience. There’s a carefully curated wine list for wine lovers, a passionate pursuit that has resulted in an exclusive collection of 75 to 100 bottles. Each wine, handpicked to highlight the grape’s innate character, complements the restaurant’s ambiance and menu.

So, if you find yourself longing for a taste of Anna Maria’s prime dining, go to The Waterfront Restaurant, where every meal is a trip down memory lane.

Anna Maria Oyster Bar

For over 25 years, Anna Maria Oyster Bar has been a culinary staple and one of the top restaurants on Anna Maria Island. More than just a restaurant, it’s an institution showcasing the essence of island dining – great food, excellent value, and a welcoming, family-friendly ambiance.

Stepping into any Anna Maria Oyster Bar location, guests are immediately greeted by its dedicated staff’s genuine warmth and smiles. Their commitment to ensuring a top-notch dining experience makes every visitor feel less like a guest and more like family. It’s this very essence of belongingness that keeps people coming back.

Of course, the food plays a starring role. Known for their daily specials, AMOB’s All-You-Can-Eat Fish & Chips on Mondays is a crowd favorite. But that’s just the beginning. Throughout the week, diners can relish offerings like Lobster Night on Tuesdays and Wine Down Wednesday, where wine enthusiasts can enjoy 50% off all wines by the bottle at the UTC location. 

With Happy Hours galore and tantalizing specials like Slammin’ Salmon and Prime Rib, Anna Maria Oyster Bar promises a dining experience that’s not just flavorful but also uniquely Anna Maria.

Beach House Waterfront Restaurant

Imagine a tranquil spot where the gentle whisper of waves serenading you merges seamlessly with the symphony of flavors on your plate. That’s the allure of the Beach House Waterfront Restaurant on Anna Maria Island. Positioned gracefully on 650 feet of untouched Gulf-front beach, this place has evolved from its origins as the old Harbor House restaurant.

The transformation began in 1993 when Ed Chiles purchased the Harbor House. Envisioning a perfect blend of indoor and outdoor dining with reasonably priced, mouthwatering seafood, he laid the foundation for the Beach House. Today, the restaurant is a testament to that vision, offering guests an enchanting dining space on its climate-friendly outdoor deck. From this vantage point, diners can witness Anna Maria Island’s signature sunsets, painting the sky with a kaleidoscope of colors every evening.

But the Beach House is not just about stunning views. It boasts a menu that is both sustainable and sumptuous. With a focus on farm-to-fork produce, each dish speaks of freshness and the restaurant’s commitment to sustainability.

The Porch Restaurant

In the heart of Anna Maria Island, set within one of its earliest constructed homes, lies a dining haven that seamlessly marries history with gourmet delights: The Porch Restaurant. Though its doors have only been open since July 2021, it’s rapidly making waves in the island’s culinary scene.

Upon entering The Porch, guests are immediately greeted by a curated menu that boasts signature dishes, seasonal entrées, and an array of beverage choices ranging from specialty spritzers to an extensive selection of beers and wines. It’s not just about serving food; it’s about presenting dishes crafted with passion and top-notch ingredients.

The Ugly Grouper

Nestled in the vibrant heart of Anna Maria Island, The Ugly Grouper isn’t just another seafood joint; it’s a complete experience. With its alluring blend of local seafood and a lively atmosphere, this spot promises more than just unforgettable meals; it promises memories that last a lifetime.

As you approach, the giant Ugly Grouper statue stands as an unmistakable landmark, hinting at the fun and flair that awaits within. But don’t let the name fool you; while things might get a tad ‘ugly’ in jest, the essence of this place is pure joy and entertainment. Families flock to The Ugly Grouper, not just for its delectable dishes but for its engaging activities. 

Where to Stay

Planning a trip to Anna Maria Island? Look no further than Anna Maria Island Inn. This unique resort hotel offers many choices to fit every traveler’s dream, a tapestry of hospitality spread across eight distinct locations on the pristine shores of Anna Maria Island, Florida.

Dreaming of waking up to the gentle sounds of the waves crashing onto the shore? Anna Maria Island Inn’s breathtaking beachfront luxury accommodations provide the perfect setting. Those traveling with family can opt for poolside family suites, ensuring kids and adults alike have their share of fun.

The ‘Driftwood’ Anna Maria Island accommodations, located merely two blocks from the island’s white sandy beaches, are ideal for many visitors. A short stroll will lead you to local restaurants, shops, and the myriad Anna Maria Island restaurants that promise a culinary journey.

But if a touch of tropical luxury is what you seek, Captain’s Quarters at Anna Maria Island Inn is your go-to. With chic, upgraded units, a sparkling new pool, spa, and a secluded BBQ area set amidst tropical flora, relaxation is a guarantee. Furthermore, its proximity to the bustling Bridge Street ensures you’re always close to the island’s popular shopping and dining spots.

So, whether you’re exploring hotels on Anna Maria Island or looking for the perfect Anna Maria Island accommodations, Anna Maria Island Inn is the perfect place. Don’t just take our word for it; come experience the magic for yourself. View all of our Anna Maria Island accommodations and book your stay today!